Layers of deceit: Why do so many recipes contain a lie about onions?
May 3, 2012 by LindsayOver at Slate, Tony Scocca is fed up with recipes that perpetrate lies; in particular, the fallacy that you can caramelize onions in 10 minutes. He quotes recipes from such respectable sources as The New York Times, Boston Globe, Washington Post, and Madhur Jaffrey, all of which have published recipes with a 5 – 10 minute time period for caramelizing onions. Yet, as Scocca proves, and as Julia Child confirms, it simply takes 35 to 45 minutes to properly caramelize onions.
Why the myth? Scocca hypothesizes that the demand for short, 30-minute or under recipes is so intense that recipe writers are simply misleading their readers as to how long it takes to properly cook onions and, by extension, to properly perform other kitchen techniques. And, as he points out, there “is the deeper problem with all the deceit around the question of caramelized onions. The premise is wrong. The faster you try to do it, the more you waste your time.”
We’d be interested in hearing whether any of our community members feel there’s validity to this argument. Do you believe some recipes have encouraged incorrect or abbreviated techniques to be able to put an “under 30-minute” label on a recipe?
Categories
- All Posts (6622)
- Antipasto (1989)
- Author Articles (241)
- Book News (919)
- Cookbook Giveaways (945)
- Cookbook Lovers (247)
- Cooking Tips (97)
- Culinary News (298)
- Food Biz People (538)
- Food Online (758)
- Holidays & Celebrations (257)
- New Cookbooks (140)
- Recipes (1442)
- Shelf Life With Susie (231)
- What's New on EYB (129)
Archives
Latest Comments
- eliza on How well do you know eggs?
- EliseNMA on Let them eat snake
- ScottKeene1 on The New Cooking School Cookbook: Advanced Fundamentals Cookbook Giveaway
- ScottKeene1 on Guild of Food Writers Award Winners 2021
- ScottKeene1 on Guild of Food Writers Award Winners 2021
- TBipp on Mother’s Day Gift Guide and Giveaway
- Jow on Beatrix Bakes Another Slice Cookbook Giveaway
- Jow on Sugarcane – Cookbook Giveaway
- Jow on Second Helpings – Cookbook Giveaway
- Jow on Every Last Bite Cookbook Giveaway