Rick Bayless and controversy over “authentic” Mexican foodMay 5, 2013 by Lindsay
It’s Cinco de Mayo, which is actually almost more of an American holiday than a Mexican one. It technically celebrates a battle than occurred in the Mexican province of Puebla, but became a holiday that Mexican-Americans encouraged to signify pride in their heritage. And just as with Cinco de Mayo, the concept of what is “authentic” Mexican food, vs. Mexican-American food, is also a bit hazy. Ironically, that haziness is proving to be the cause for another battle between Rick Bayless – an American chefs who is most famous for creating “authentic” Mexican food – and the state of California.
In the first of two incidents, Bayless purportedly “introduced Southern Californians to Mexican food. As ABC news sums it up, there was “ a comment Bayless made (or didn’t make, as Bayless himself maintains) about introducing Southern California diners to “authentic” Mexican cuisine. Long story short: In 2010, Pulitzer Prize-winning food writer Jonathan Gold, addressing attendees as a fund-raiser for an association of Latino journalists,criticized Bayless for his role in Red O, a restaurant that, as he characterized it, positioned itself as introducing authentic Mexican food to Los Angeles — a city long-influenced by Mexicans, Mexican-Americans, and their respective, often overlapping food traditions. Bayless responded to Gold’s comments online, tweeting directly to Gold that he “[t]hought a Pulitzer meant you checked facts. Sneering at me for something I never said is either mean or sloppy. I’m offended.”
More recently, however, in San Francisco, in an interview with Zagat, Bayless is quoted as saying, “San Francisco doesn’t really have much of a Mexican food tradition aside from the taquerias in the Mission, which is a fairly limited thing.” This did not go over well in San Franicsco. In a blog written by Gustavo Arellano (author of Taco USA), titled Rick Bayless Insults Yet Another California City’s Mexican Food Traditions, Arellano writes, “Um, excuse me? No tradition? Idiot obviously didn’t read my Taco USA, let alone ask the Mexicans who’ve lived in the Mission even before Bayless was some Okie manning a barbecue pit whether their traditions are nonexistent. Idiot didn’t even visit San Francisco’s vibrant Yucatecan food scene, beneficiaries of the largest Yucateco community in the United States. And to call the Mission burrito a “fairly limited thing” is akin to calling the 1974 Cadillac Eldorado a fairly short car.”
We love Mexican food in all forms – and think it’s probably a good thing that there really can’t be a fine line between “athentic” and “non-authentic” Mexican food. After all, culture changes (especially those involving food) that are inclusive rather than exclusionary should be welcomed. While this controversy doesn’t change our over-all opinion of Bayless and the wonderful cookbooks he’s written, it does make us wish that he would be a little more thoughtful in his interviews.
Photo courtesy of Facebook
- kennethjohngilmour on Small Batch Bakes – Cookbook Giveaway
- frozen16 on Meat-Free Mexican Cookbook Giveaway
- frozen16 on Small Batch Bakes – Cookbook Giveaway
- cellenly on Delicious Gatherings: Recipes to Celebrate Together Prize Package
- Badgerlord on Good & Sweet: Quick Bites & Cookbook Giveaway
- pie4u on Small Batch Bakes – Cookbook Giveaway
- GrooveHeart on The Spanish Home Kitchen – Cookbook Giveaway
- GrooveHeart on Green Kitchen: Quick + Slow Cookbook Giveaway
- GregH on Around the Table – Cookbook Giveaway
- riley on Food news antipasto